Forums > Windsurfing General

Best board

Reply
Created by Ben1973 > 9 months ago, 2 Jul 2020
Ben1973
908 posts
2 Jul 2020 6:19AM
Thumbs Up

Who makes it? Not talking about how it sails but it's construction. Who's got the right mix of durability and weight, who's finish is the best, who fin box is actually the right size etc?

Gestalt
QLD, 14123 posts
2 Jul 2020 8:23AM
Thumbs Up

you will need to go to custom manufacturers to get the best built board.

Mastbender
1972 posts
2 Jul 2020 7:40AM
Thumbs Up

"The one I just bought!" Could be what's goes thru most people's mind.
But in reality it is the one you just bought, until you use it a few times, then most likely not so much.

Mark _australia
WA, 22089 posts
2 Jul 2020 8:09AM
Thumbs Up

Construction peaked around the mid 2000's I reckon, with double sandwich waveboards that lasted.

Since then its been a race to the bottom with weight savings that many of us just don't want, and cost considerations. Lots of it has been removing materials in some areas gradually gradually - til they all break and then next year they go add a bit again.

FWIW I think the best life and least damage I've seen is in the Fanatic / RRD etc wood/carbon-innegra combination, and the Starboard wood/carbon. Nuevo etc were tough as. Most Starboard wood finished degraded cosmetically but easy fixed.

Some brands continue to think we want eggshells. I'd rather have the 500g under my feet thanks.

Ben1973
908 posts
2 Jul 2020 8:32AM
Thumbs Up

Agree with the above, I'd add Severne in there as both my Fox's look great after a year plus of hard use which is more than I can say for others I've used. Thinking I might give Fanatic a go next just for old times sake as my first real performance board 20odd years ago was one

kato
VIC, 3340 posts
2 Jul 2020 12:34PM
Thumbs Up

Just saying, I'm still using an 09 CarbonArt and I know of an 05 still going strong

Gestalt
QLD, 14123 posts
2 Jul 2020 1:26PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
kato said..
Just saying, I'm still using an 09 CarbonArt and I know of an 05 still going strong

Yup. Ditto on my nxs board.

Gestalt
QLD, 14123 posts
2 Jul 2020 1:40PM
Thumbs Up

while i've been working through my eco board construction i worked up a spreadsheet of typical layups.

i doubt each manufacturer is going to advertise their special sauce but what was available online i tabulated. ie. this may not be exact and i had to join the dots in a few spots.






philn
725 posts
3 Jul 2020 12:43AM
Thumbs Up

Witchcraft Dyneema is supposed to be pretty damn amazing. I have not personally sailed one.

boardsurfr
WA, 2202 posts
3 Jul 2020 12:57AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mark _australia said..
Construction peaked around the mid 2000's I reckon, with double sandwich waveboards that lasted.

Since then its been a race to the bottom with weight savings that many of us just don't want, and cost considerations. Lots of it has been removing materials in some areas gradually gradually - til they all break and then next year they go add a bit again.

FWIW I think the best life and least damage I've seen is in the Fanatic / RRD etc wood/carbon-innegra combination, and the Starboard wood/carbon. Nuevo etc were tough as. Most Starboard wood finished degraded cosmetically but easy fixed.

Some brands continue to think we want eggshells. I'd rather have the 500g under my feet thanks.


I've seen some double sandwich parts in a Fanatic freestyle board when I put tracks in; covered only part of the board, though. That particular board has seen quite a few years of intense (ab)use and is still going strong. But just recently, I saw a Fanatic board for winging that was such poor construction (thin fiberglass directly over EPS core) that a guy managed to break the nose with his knee in a crash while winging. On another Fanatic FS board, I had multiple failures at the edge of a wood enforcement panel. I'd made the mistake of often placing my foot too far to the outside, next to where the wood panel ended. In my defense, that had never been an issue on an almost identical board (which, however, did not have a wood reinforcement panel). So the devil can be in the details.

wsurfn
76 posts
3 Jul 2020 2:57AM
Thumbs Up

Flikka

mr love
VIC, 2296 posts
3 Jul 2020 8:42AM
Thumbs Up

You would have to chuck Pete Ross's OES boards near the top of that list. The speed board he built me many, many, many years ago is still going strong and light as. The Atomicsurf boards he is building me are bullit proof. Ditto for Carbonart

Basher
531 posts
3 Jul 2020 7:23AM
Thumbs Up

Not sure I'd go with many of the comments here.

In my experience I have never broken any board, despite having a lot of them - or despite sailing a favourite board all the time in our windy season.
What I find is that some people break boards all the time, whilst others don't.
The same board breakers have been to 'custom' brands for their strongest layup, supposedly better than any production board, and yet they still have the same problems and those custom build boards last no longer, in their hands.

Just an observation.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 7917 posts
3 Jul 2020 9:24AM
Thumbs Up

Windtechs are solidly built.

Ben1973
908 posts
3 Jul 2020 8:00AM
Thumbs Up

This board lasted me 2weeks before it died.


Ben1973
908 posts
3 Jul 2020 8:02AM
Thumbs Up

Large void in foam, very thin layer of glass with looked like it had never touched resin. this wasn't in just one spot either

Mark _australia
WA, 22089 posts
3 Jul 2020 8:24AM
Thumbs Up

Doesn't matter what materials you put in it, if you don't wet out the glass properly.

Ben that's a SUP..?

powersloshin
NSW, 1654 posts
3 Jul 2020 1:50PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mark _australia said..
Construction peaked around the mid 2000's I reckon, with double sandwich waveboards that lasted.




Agree with Mark, I have a JP Slalom Pro III (2007) that is as solid as a rock as well as pretty light. Model is 69 liters, I've done 3000 kms with it. Recently I have shortened the nose and I realized the skin is super strong, I think they used kevlar in it.






Gestalt
QLD, 14123 posts
3 Jul 2020 6:43PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ben1973 said..
This board lasted me 2weeks before it died.




You should name the brand. Thats shoddy work. I'll asume it's not from a custom builder because typically they have enough pride in their work to try and do things properly but who would know.


I have heard stories of a particular brands boards creasing after little use and the warranty being rejected. Same brand you see boards coming up second hand that are being sold as creased.

Orange Whip
QLD, 1039 posts
3 Jul 2020 7:32PM
Thumbs Up

How much control do the major brands have over quality at the cheap labour manufacturing places they use? If John Doe is having a bad day would he or she be able to throw out the script and cut corners and not care about the finished product? Is it deliberate by the brands in all cases to cut costs?

Grantmac
1953 posts
4 Jul 2020 1:41AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Orange Whip said..
How much control do the major brands have over quality at the cheap labour manufacturing places they use? If John Doe is having a bad day would he or she be able to throw out the script and cut corners and not care about the finished product? Is it deliberate by the brands in all cases to cut costs?


I've had one if those boards. Obvious damage post lamination that was simply filled with putty then sent for paint.
I don't ever buy new boards but if I did it would be from a small manufacturer. When I buy used at least I can see if any obvious defects have shown themselves.

Ben1973
908 posts
5 Jul 2020 9:54AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mark _australia said..
Doesn't matter what materials you put in it, if you don't wet out the glass properly.

Ben that's a SUP..?


Not a sup, a 150liter freeride board. After the fin box fell out due to not being glued in I cut in up and found a few areas like this.

Gestalt
QLD, 14123 posts
5 Jul 2020 12:10PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ben1973 said..

Mark _australia said..
Doesn't matter what materials you put in it, if you don't wet out the glass properly.

Ben that's a SUP..?



Not a sup, a 150liter freeride board. After the fin box fell out due to not being glued in I cut in up and found a few areas like this.


You really need to name the brand. As a user group how are we supposed to get better built gear if the manufacturers aren't taken to task.

Subsonic
WA, 2963 posts
5 Jul 2020 10:14AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Orange Whip said..
How much control do the major brands have over quality at the cheap labour manufacturing places they use? If John Doe is having a bad day would he or she be able to throw out the script and cut corners and not care about the finished product? Is it deliberate by the brands in all cases to cut costs?


I think thats somewhat the difference between custom and mass production.

to a custom builder, each board is a project, quality control is a big part of each build. To a worker doing a single part of a board build, with 20 more boards to do on their shift, not so much. I think the only control a brand has over quality control is how often they visit the factory, and QA from said factory, if they ask for it.

JakeNN
351 posts
5 Jul 2020 11:52AM
Thumbs Up

My preference is:
a) zero warranty
b) significant savings in weight
c) significant reduction in strength
d) significant reduction in cost

So a very fragile board, say 4kg for a 85L waveboard, price after discount about RRP$1500 (not RRP$3000+) and no warranty then I accept the risk with any issues.

JakeNN
351 posts
5 Jul 2020 11:54AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Subsonic said..
I think the only control a brand has over quality control is how often they visit the factory, and QA from said factory, if they ask for it.


Warranty risk transfers from the brand to the manufacturer, so it is their (eg Cobra's) interest to manufacture well without shortcuts.

BSN101
WA, 2244 posts
5 Jul 2020 12:26PM
Thumbs Up

There's a cool vid of Patrik smashing one of his AirInside boards. Tough as, he smashed it real hard with an extension til it broke. MAD!!! Then he sunk it. Jumped on it but it didn't sink. Weighed 150kg. Drained it the next video was the fix. Spears to be a good build. Prob pricey but his boards are keepers

petermac33
WA, 6415 posts
5 Jul 2020 2:56PM
Thumbs Up

The only problem with the airinside boards is were you to have a bad catapult on them there is next to no give on them so any potential injury is likely to be more severe.

In rough chop they sail a bit harsher than a conventional board if your technique is lacking or you are having a bad day trimming the board.

Overall they offer better performance and ive heard they never go soft but I am not convinced they are any sweeter to sail.

BSN101
WA, 2244 posts
5 Jul 2020 6:32PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BSN101 said..
There's a cool vid of Patrik smashing one of his AirInside boards. Tough as, he smashed it real hard with an extension til it broke. MAD!!! Then he sunk it. Jumped on it but it didn't sink. Weighed 150kg. Drained it the next video was the fix. Spears to be a good build. Prob pricey but his boards are keepers


Ep 3 -Does the AIRINSIDE board sink

Subsonic
WA, 2963 posts
5 Jul 2020 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
JakeNN said..


Subsonic said..
I think the only control a brand has over quality control is how often they visit the factory, and QA from said factory, if they ask for it.




Warranty risk transfers from the brand to the manufacturer, so it is their (eg Cobra's) interest to manufacture well without shortcuts.



Im sure that weighs quite heavily on the managers/upper management, even the person responsible for putting the the little QA sticker on.


the dude who's meant to blow the board down properly right before smoko, not so much.

DarrylG
WA, 494 posts
5 Jul 2020 8:59PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
petermac33 said..
The only problem with the airinside boards is were you to have a bad catapult on them there is next to no give on them so any potential injury is likely to be more severe.

In rough chop they sail a bit harsher than a conventional board if your technique is lacking or you are having a bad day trimming the board.

Overall they offer better performance and ive heard they never go soft but I am not convinced they are any sweeter to sail.


I have spent a fair bit of time on the airinside boards Pete. They can be soft riding. The advantage is they can actually have areas of flex built in, ie nose section of bottom. Then incredibly stiff / power transfer around fin box. a huge amount of time has been put into the feel of the boards. It's not as simple as making everything as stiff as possible.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Best board" started by Ben1973